The U.S. Credit Card Industry in 2009
Mathias Kruettli
|
Dec 12, 2008
While the global economy is still struggling with the consequences of the subprime (and now prime) mortgage crises, experts believe that the crisis will soon extent to the credit card industry. Unemployment in the U.S. is likely to increase further, and this will cause a jump in defaults on credit card debt. Since the total outstanding credit card debt in the U.S. has reached a level of 1 trillion USD, higher charge-off rates on credit card portfolios could turn out to have devastating effects for U.S. commercial banks. In our new RGE Monitor paper, we forecast write-downs on U.S. credit card debt receivables in 2009. We create two models which provide estimates for the future real growth rate of revolving consumer debt and the future net recovery charge-off rates, respectively. Revolving consumer debt is used as an approximation for credit card debt. The predictions of the write-downs are divided into nine scenarios. These scenarios are based on variations in the forecasts of the independent variables. In the worst case scenario the write-downs could be as high as 146 billion USD. In the best case the write-downs will be around 64 billion USD. We come to the conclusion that write-downs in 2009 are likely to be significantly higher than in 2008 (50 billion USD). Considering that the total write-downs on credit card receivables have never exceeded 50 billion USD in the past, it is doubtful if the credit card issuers could absorb write-downs of far above 100 billion USD. Credit Card Debt Write-Downs in 2009 (Million USD)
![]() These additional write-downs on credit card receivables are a serious threat to U.S. commercial banks, which are already financially weak because of the mortgage crisis and its aftermath. Furthermore, the high securitization level of credit card portfolios spreads the risk of high write-downs throughout the financial system. Additionally, Federal Reserve Board data, which we have used for our paper, indicates that credit card issuers will not be able to circumvent higher future write-downs by adjusting their lending standards.
Check out the full paper at: http://www.rgemonitor.com/redir.php?sid=1&tgid=10000&cid=309291
Comments
Uno
Reply to this comment
By r0tiNeK on 2008-12-10 23:24:03
Charge-Offs Start to Shred Card Issuers
http://online.wsj.com/article/SB122895752803296651.html?mod=testMod "More credit-card holders who fall behind on their payments are eventually defaulting, deepening losses for thousands of banks that issue plastic. The worsening trend indicates that charge-off rates among credit-card issuers, which stood at more than 6% in the third quarter, are poised to rise more than expected in the fourth quarter and into next year. That means additional misery for financial firms already besieged with losses on everything from soured mortgages to bad bets on capital markets. ..."
Reply to this comment
By eparisi on 2008-12-11 00:25:32
Mathias, this is a fantastic paper... I really loved the footnote describing how Americans are increasingly relying upon their credit cards to pay off their medical expenses.... That is causing significant increases in credit card debt that is being securitized---and with the grim economy, such debt may not wind up to be performing...
I just want to say that perhaps we should use different unemployment numbers than those published by the Bureau of Labor Statistics... Kevin Phillips published the following paper in Harper's Magazine back in May 2008 where he showed biases in government statistics created solely out of political expediency (http://www.mindfully.org/Reform/2008/Pollyanna-Creep-Economy1may08.htm)... The graph showing how the BLS calculates unemployment is most instructive. Should they potentially use the red line depicting the U-6 series in the BLS monthly stats.... By that estimate, in the spring 2008 unemployment was already over 9% using U-6 numbers!!!! By now, I'm sure those numbers are much higher (I haven't checked yet). What effects would placing the U-6 series in your model have on your results? If I get time over the weekend or over the XMAS holidays, I'll see if I can do that just for fun and post my results here on the RGE Monitor blog....
Hide reply
Reply to this comment
By Nicholas T. Dahlheim on 2008-12-12 11:50:11
Nicholas,
I did not realize the issue with the unemployment rate. Thanks for letting me know!
Reply to this comment
By Mathias Kruettli on 2008-12-19 16:21:22
Credit card debt as all other debt that affects the financial markets will be bailed out when the time is critical as this is the practice. The problem with this practice will be during the time period when the US itself will become likened to the auto industry to the rest of the world and its practice of printing to save the economy will be its downfall. Since the US government is the lender of last resort then there is no one else to turn to when the US reaches its own credit default. The end game will be the same, If the US had allowed the weakest companies to fail only stepping in to save the ones that are most critical to the US then the US would have had the ability to save itself from its own financial default. When your house is on fire and you have only a few minutes to retrieve the most important items so you can rebuild. Unlike the US Government in this scenario is trying to remove every piece of furniture and going back in to retrieve the dogs bowl and curtains’. This is irresponsible and reckless, the government also assumes that as soon as the fire that gutted the home is put out then the entire family can move back in and go on about their lives as if nothing has happen. In reality the structure collapsed on Uncle Sam and he was burned to death in the fire.
Reply to this comment
By Central alabam on 2008-12-12 12:59:12
I wonder how many families are feeding themselves with credit debt at McDonald's alone.
Reply to this comment
By Guest on 2009-01-07 15:04:04
Well, all the US brands that vie with one another to
pulls out the credit card from the consumers pocket have verily contributed to aggravating this crisis. This plastic crisis started by US will surely spread to entire world. It is a just a matter of time. Globalizing the crisis is what Mr.Bush meant when he was harping about "globalization" in every forum in the world. Thanks to America & Mr. Bush for their immense contribution to world prosperity(?)
Reply to this comment
By Anonymous on 2009-01-16 09:56:03
Well, all your suppositions are perfectly logical, you got that right but I prefer to keep my optimism and reject any other dark predictions. We are already having a hard time facing the mortgage crises, I think that for the moment is wise to stay focused on that.
Garry, credit card merchant account
Reply to this comment
By garry on 2009-02-20 08:39:25
Well, all your suppositions are perfectly logical, you got that right but I prefer to keep my optimism and reject any other dark predictions. We are already having a hard time facing the mortgage crises, I think that for the moment is wise to stay focused on that.
Garry, credit card merchant account
Reply to this comment
By garry on 2009-02-20 08:40:48
اليوم جايبلكم برنامج جميل فعلا و ليه مميزات كتيرة هيتم شرحها تفصيلا بالتتابع البرنامج بيسمح لك بعمل أتصال دولي لمدة 30 دقيقة كحد أقص يوميا، 30 دقيقة مقسمة على دقيقتين لكل إتصال. طبعا لازم تكون مجهز المايك و الهيدفون قبل كل شيء و نتابع طريقة التحميل بالصور اضغط هنااااااااااااااااااااااااااااااااااااااااااا http://affiliate.adphone.com/click.asp?pid=36382&pcode=350765 واى استفسار او توقف انا ايميلى مفتوح علطول doby2009@hotmail.com yossry2100@yahoo.com
Reply to this comment
By Guest on 2009-04-15 21:18:04
Welcome to visit our store, we've got all brand new Nike air max for you there, all styles are fasionable. We also offer all lines of nike shoes, inluding the air force ones, nike air max, nike dunks, and of course, the timberland boots. The shipping is free for all shoes. 40% off for discount.
Reply to this comment
By Guest on 2009-11-16 23:49:19
Women are crazy about these luxury name brand handbags. Such as, coach handbags says, she wanna go home, chanel handbags says, she wanna stay here, and don't go anywhere. But gucci handbagssays, this city is beautiful, she loves this city and the people here. For the prada handbags, she wants to stay with louis vuitton handbags, they are good friends. All the name brand handbags are on sale here, you can get them at amazing prices.
Reply to this comment
By Guest on 2009-11-17 20:29:42
Welcome to our website for Nike SB, Nike Dunks and Nike Shoes, they are really cheap for you, so don't hesitate, cheapest Air Force Ones and <Nike Air Max are here waiting for you!
Reply to this comment
By Guest on 2009-11-18 01:22:11
Post A CommentYou must be logged into the site to post a comment. You may login with your username and password in the upper right hand corner of this page. If you do not have a login, you may register for an account. |
Subscriber Login
Also on RGE Monitor
Recent Posts:
Topics
Archives
Restoring Financial Stability
How to Repair a Failed System A Bird's-Eye View—The
Financial Crisis of 2007-2009: Causes and Remedies
Agenda for Reform
Building an International Monetary and Financial System for the 21st Century
by the Reinventing Bretton Woods Committee Download the ebook |
||||||||||||